Hello Bo,
I understand by your statement in your previous reply in this thread (reply #10), you don’t think that there are any “cougars” in the area and that reports of such are in your words “
just somewhat ignorant or otherwise being spread by those that had rather continue "old wives tales" as opposed to doing their own research”. I expect a lot of folks may agree with you. Everyone has an opinion, and “to each their own”. As far as your reply #13, (which I take as a response to my question in reply # 11
plus your reading of my report at
http://www.linvillegorge.net/smf/index.php?topic=268.0 reply #1), and with all due respect, I want to respond.
I understand the “hard evidence” part but I also understand that among the many things science has proven, it’s proven time and time again that in some cases that what once was believed to be a rock solid fact, turned out to be false. If my particular incident (sighting) is
not a case of someone’s "pet" mountain lion/cougar having escaped or something of the sort (as another poster mentioned the possibility of), and the consensus of the “scientific community” pertaining to this subject along with the time frame as stated is there are no big cats in the area in question, then I can personally say the scientific community is wrong in this case. Please keep in mind I am not implying that there was/is any particular number of them in the area. I am basing my report only on the one I saw, when I saw it, and nothing else.
As for my report of my sighting, I certainly have no reason to exaggerate it, especially to this group of so many avid outdoorsmen/outdoorswomen. I am not a scientist, but I
can tell the difference between a bear, dog, dear, cougar, coyote and bobcat, and have been fortunate enough over my life time to have seen each with my own eyes (all before the time of my sighting of the big cat in my report). Even though I’m not sure as to what a “big cat” in this area technically would be called (cougar, mountain lion, panther, etc…), I know what I saw… and that was a “big cat”.
You also stated
“In other words, "show me." My mind is not totally closed, but I want to see the proof.” I appreciate that you feel this way, and hope that if there still is a big cat (or cats) in this area, you will have the opportunity to see it (from a safe position of course). It was hands down the most exciting thing I personally have seen in the outdoor environment due to the fact of the rarity.
Though I don’t have any “physical” proof to offer up to you and I can only offer up my written report… I stand by it.
Glen